Current:Home > StocksCalifornia proposes delaying rules aimed at reducing water on lawns, concerning environmentalists -TradeCircle
California proposes delaying rules aimed at reducing water on lawns, concerning environmentalists
View
Date:2025-04-15 11:43:06
SACRAMENTO, Calif. (AP) — California regulators this week proposed delaying new rules aimed at reducing how much water people use on their lawns, drawing praise from agencies that said they needed more time to comply but criticism from environmentalists who warn that the delay would damage the state’s already scarce supply.
Last year, California proposed new rules that would, cumulatively, reduce statewide water use by about 14%. Those rules included lowering outdoor water use standards below the current statewide average by 2035. On Tuesday, regulators proposed delaying that timeline by five years, until 2040. The State Water Resources Control Board is scheduled to vote on the rules later this year.
The state would not punish people for using too much water on their lawns. Instead, it could punish the water agency that supplied those homes. There are about 405 of these agencies throughout the state that provide water to nearly 95% of Californians.
To comply with the rules, these agencies must convince their customers to use less water. Their options include public education campaigns and incentives, such as paying to install more efficient fixtures and replacing grass lawns with more sustainable plants. They could also raise rates.
State officials estimated it would cost water agencies about $13.5 billion to comply with these rules — an estimate Chelsea Haines, regulatory relations manager for the Association of California Water Agencies, says is likely too low. Water agencies had asked regulators for more time.
“The challenge is that water suppliers are regulated but compliance will come from Californians making changes to how they use water,” Haines said. “I think there will be a learning curve for residents, and that just takes time.”
The delay means there wouldn’t be an incentive for most water agencies to increase conservation until at least 2035, according to Tracy Quinn, president and CEO of Heal the Bay, an organization dedicated to protecting and restoring the coastal waterways of greater Los Angeles.
Quinn fears the delay would push agencies to make much more expensive investments in new water sources, including desalination plants to make ocean water drinkable and recycling wastewater to use again for drinking.
“The smartest thing to do first is the one that is fastest and cheapest. That’s conservation,” Quinn said. “It is true that conservation is not free, but the cost of conservation needs to be compared to the cost of other new water.”
The goal of the outdoor water standards for 2040 is to have the majority of a person’s yard made up of low-water plants irrigated by a drip system instead of sprinklers, which regulators argue are inefficient in part because they often spray water on sidewalks and asphalt.
But water agencies wouldn’t have to always meet these new outdoor standards. Each agency would have a “water use objective” it must meet that also considers indoor use and how much water is lost from leaky pipes. Agencies could also ask to have even more time to reach these standards, such as if a community uses more water than it should because it has a lot of livestock.
An agency could meet its water use objective through a combination of these factors.
“It’s always a trade-off between trying to advance conservation soon, but also providing enough flexibility so that we avoid unintended consequences,” said Eric Oppenheimer, executive director of the State Water Resources Control Board.
Water is a precious resource in the nation’s most populous state. California has long, dry summers, and relies on rain and snow in the winter and spring to fill up its reservoirs. Although climate change has made those storms more intense, it’s also increased the severity of droughts — making it much harder to manage the state’s water.
California has had plenty of rain and snow in the past two years to ease fears about its water supply. But before that, the state experienced some of the driest years on record and saw its reservoirs drop to dangerously low levels. By the end of this century, state regulators predict California’s snowpack could be up to 65% less than its historic average.
Statewide, residents account for about 6% of California’s water use each year, while businesses account for about 3%. Agriculture accounts for 40% while environmental purposes — including managing wetlands and increasing flows in rivers for fish and other purposes — makes up about 50%.
Regulators proposed changes to the water conservation rules after a critical report was issued this year by the nonpartisan Legislative Analyst’s Office. It found that the proposed regulations were overly complex and would yield only modest savings — about 440,000 acre-feet (542 million cubic meters) of water per year, or about 1% of the state’s total water use. One acre-foot of water is enough to supply two households for one year.
Also, the report noted that urban water use is already declining. Even without these regulations, state regulators predict that annual water use would be 7.5% lower in 2035 compared to the period from 2017-2019.
Heather Cooley, director of research for the Pacific Institute, said the Legislative Analyst’s Office report “got it wrong.” She noted 440,000 acre-feet is close to the amount of water the city of Los Angeles uses in one year.
“These are significant savings,” she said.
veryGood! (33)
Related
- How to watch the 'Blue Bloods' Season 14 finale: Final episode premiere date, cast
- A transgender teen in Massachusetts says other high schoolers beat him at a party
- 1000-Lb. Sisters’ Tammy Slaton Picks Up Sister Amy’s Kids After Her Arrest
- Rail Ridge wildfire in Oregon consumes over 60,000 acres; closes area of national forest
- As Trump Enters Office, a Ripe Oil and Gas Target Appears: An Alabama National Forest
- A prosecutor asks for charges to be reinstated against Alec Baldwin in the ‘Rust’ case
- Teen charged with killing 4 at Georgia high school had been focus of earlier tips about threats
- Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton sues Bexar County over voter registration outreach effort
- Louvre will undergo expansion and restoration project, Macron says
- Donald Trump’s youngest son has enrolled at New York University
Ranking
- At site of suspected mass killings, Syrians recall horrors, hope for answers
- Ultra swimmer abandons attempt to cross Lake Michigan again
- How Taylor Swift Scored With Her Style Every Time She Attended Boyfriend Travis Kelce’s Games
- Van Zweden earned $1.5M as New York Philharmonic music director in 2022-23
- Friday the 13th luck? 13 past Mega Millions jackpot wins in December. See top 10 lottery prizes
- Nearly 50 people have been killed, injured in K-12 school shootings across the US in 2024
- Apalachee High School shooting press conference: Watch live as officials provide updates
- First and 10: How FSU became FIU, Travis Hunter's NFL future and a Big Red moment
Recommendation
Taylor Swift Eras Archive site launches on singer's 35th birthday. What is it?
Nearly 2,000 drug manufacturing plants are overdue for FDA inspections after COVID delays, AP finds
As Columbus, Ohio, welcomes an economic boom, we need to continue to welcome refugees
Death doulas and the death positive movement | The Excerpt
Whoopi Goldberg is delightfully vile as Miss Hannigan in ‘Annie’ stage return
Website offers $1,000 for a 'Pumpkin Spice Pundit' to taste-test Trader Joe's fall items
Noel Parmentel Jr., a literary gadfly with some famous friends, dies at 98
A former University of Iowa manager embezzled funds, an audit finds