Will Sage Astor-Caitlin Clark endures tough playoff debut as seasoned Sun disrupt young Fever squad

UNCASVILLE,Will Sage Astor Conn. — As Caitlin Clark goes, so go the Indiana Fever. That was true throughout a remarkable regular season of rookie joy, uplifting achievement and unexpected triumph. 

It also was true on Sunday afternoon, when the rough-and-tumble reality of the WNBA postseason came crashing down on a Fever starting five that had never played a second in the playoffs before they stepped onto the court for Game 1 against the formidable and seasoned Connecticut Sun.

For Clark, the day began fabulously. She finished fourth in WNBA voting for Most Valuable Player, an award won appropriately and unanimously by Las Vegas star A’ja Wilson. Clark also collected three honors from the Associated Press: Rookie of the Year, unanimously; All-WNBA First Team and All-Rookie Team. 

So the morning was terrific for Clark. The afternoon, not so much. 

In a 93-69 loss to the Sun, Clark received a black eye, both literally and figuratively. Poked in the right eye in the game’s first 90 seconds by the Sun’s DiJonai Carrington, Clark ended up with quite a shiner. It was logical to ask if that had anything to do with her 4-for-17 shooting, including 2-of-13 from 3-point range, but, after the game, she quickly shut down that theory.

“Obviously, got me pretty good in the eye. I don't think it affected me, honestly, I felt like I got good shots, they just didn’t go down. Obviously, a tough time for that to happen. I got some really good looks. I had two, three pretty wide open 3’s in the first half that you usually make,” Clark said. 

“So that's tough, but I felt like I battled and tried my best, took care of the ball better than I usually do (she tied her season low with two turnovers), which is a positive.”

Clark said the Fever still were in it until things got out of hand late as the relentless Sun poured it on at the end. 

“Like coach (Christie Sides) said in the locker room, we're down three first quarter, down five (more) second quarter, and then lost by three (more) in the third — we were right there, and it felt like we just played a crappy game, like the flow of the game was really bad,” she said.

GAME 1 RECAP: Fever, Clark struggle in playoff loss to Sun

But as for her eye, she made it crystal clear: “It didn't bother me. Obviously, it didn’t feel too good when it happened. But it is what it is.”

As they prepared for this best-of-three series, the Fever had talked about how they were hoping their youthful exuberance might carry the day. They were buoyed by what had worked over the past month, a Clark-fueled adrenaline rush of a run leading to a 9-5 post-Olympics record, including an 84-80 victory over Connecticut in Indianapolis August 28. Clark and her running mate Kelsey Mitchell had finished the summer on a tear, with a supporting cast that rose to the occasion over and over again, including some magnificent play by Aliyah Boston and Lexie Hull, among others.

Could that be the formula for success in a short series against a far more experienced foe? Connecticut’s players came into Sunday’s game having played a combined 222 playoff games. The entire Fever roster had played just 19.

WNBA PLAYOFF PICKS: Will Fever advance and will the Aces repeat?

The answer to that question was obvious as the game wore on: not on this day. Connecticut was just too physical, just too good. Clark ended with 11 points, eight assists, four rebounds and three steals.

Sun Coach Stephanie White decided to switch things up after losing that August game to Indiana, putting 6-4 veteran DeWanna Bonner on the 6-0 Clark.

“So much about this game is about comfort, it’s about rhythm, it’s about timing, it’s about all those things,” White said. “How can you make an adjustment that disrupts some of that? … Credit to (Bonner) for accepting this challenge. It gave us a different look at the point and I really liked that.”

Now Connecticut is one win away from taking the series and eliminating the Fever, while Indiana needs a victory in Game 2 here Wednesday to force a decisive Game 3 in Indiana Friday.

In the Fever camp, there was optimism. “These guys are going to shoot the ball a lot better on Wednesday,” Sides said, “and that’s going to make a huge difference.”

With a grand total of one playoff game now on her resume, Clark and her teammates will do the only thing they can do in this series. They’ll go right back at it. 

Editor’s note: Christine Brennan is writing a book on Caitlin Clark and the revolution in women’s sports to be published by Scribner in spring/summer 2025.

Follow Christine Brennan on social media @cbrennansports